Is a Day Trip to Montauk from NYC Worth It? Quick Facts
Thinking of swapping the city skyline for a lighthouse and crashing waves? A montauk new york day trip is a long but incredibly rewarding escape. Before you pack your beach bag, here’s a quick look at what to expect.
| Metric | Details |
|---|---|
| Distance from NYC | ~120 miles |
| Average Travel Time | 3-4 hours each way (highly variable) |
| Estimated Day Trip Cost | $120 – $220 per person |
| Best Time for a Day Trip | Weekdays in Summer (Jun-Aug); Any day in Shoulder Season (May, Sep-Oct) |
How to Get to Montauk from NYC: Train, Car, or Bus?
Getting to “The End” is part of the adventure! You have three main options, each with its own pros and cons. Choosing the right one is key to a stress-free day trip to Montauk. Let’s break them down.
By Train: The Long Island Rail Road (LIRR)
For a relaxing, scenic, and traffic-free journey, the LIRR is our top recommendation. Departing from Penn Station or Grand Central Madison, you can sit back and watch the landscape transform from urban sprawl to charming villages and finally, coastal dunes. Wondering how long is the train from nyc to montauk? It’s a consistent 3 to 3.5 hours. As for how much is the train from nyc to montauk, expect to pay around $30.50 for an off-peak one-way ticket and $42.00 for peak times. For a faster (and pricier) trip, look for the seasonal “Cannonball” express train on summer Fridays. We highly recommend booking your tickets in advance using the MTA TrainTime app.
By Car: The Scenic but Risky Drive
Driving offers the most flexibility, allowing you to explore at your own pace. The main route is the Long Island Expressway (I-495) to Route 27 (Sunrise Highway). So, how long does it take to get to montauk from nyc by car? This is the million-dollar question. On a Tuesday morning in May, it could be 2.5 hours. On a Saturday morning in July, it could easily stretch to 5-6 hours. Be warned: summer weekend traffic is legendary, and parking in Montauk is extremely limited and can be expensive. If you choose to drive, leave NYC before 7 AM.
By Bus: The Hampton Jitney
The Hampton Jitney is a fantastic compromise between the train and the car. It offers a comfortable, coach-style ride with amenities like Wi-Fi and plush seating, departing from various points in NYC. While it’s still subject to road traffic, it removes the stress of driving and parking. The journey typically takes 3-4 hours, and a one-way ticket costs between $40-$50. It’s a civilized way to travel and a popular choice for good reason.
| Method | Time | Cost (One-Way est.) | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LIRR Train | ~3-3.5 hours | ~$30 – $45 | Avoids traffic, relaxing, predictable timing | Station is a short taxi ride from town |
| Car | 2.5 – 6+ hours | ~$25 (gas) + tolls | Total flexibility, can bring more gear | Brutal traffic, extremely difficult parking |
| Hampton Jitney | 3 – 4+ hours | ~$40 – $50 | Comfortable, no driving stress, amenities | Can get stuck in traffic, less flexible |
Top 5 Things to Do on a Montauk Day Trip
You’ve made it to The End! Now, what to do? You can’t see everything in a single day, so we’ve narrowed it down to the absolute must-do experiences for a perfect Montauk day trip.
- See the Historic Montauk Point Lighthouse
No trip is complete without visiting this icon. Commissioned by President George Washington in 1792, it’s the oldest lighthouse in New York State. Climb the 137 steps for breathtaking 360-degree views of the Atlantic Ocean and Block Island Sound.
Details: Admission is ~$15 for adults. Check their website for seasonal hours, which are limited outside of summer.
Insider Tip: For the best photos, walk down the path to the beach on the left. The view of the lighthouse perched on the bluffs is more dramatic from below.
- Watch the Surfers at Ditch Plains Beach
Feel the authentic soul of Montauk at Ditch Plains. This legendary surf spot, framed by dramatic cliffs, is the perfect place to lay down a towel and watch local and visiting surfers ride the waves. The vibe is laid-back, rugged, and completely captivating.
Details: Parking requires a town permit during the peak summer season. Your best bet is to get dropped off by a taxi or ride a bike here.
Insider Tip: Don’t miss the legendary Ditch Witch food truck, serving up delicious and satisfying beach fare for decades.
- Explore the Mysteries of Camp Hero State Park
Step into a real-life episode of *Stranger Things*. This former Air Force station is home to the imposing, abandoned SAGE radar tower that fueled local legends for years. Beyond the eerie history, the park offers incredible hiking trails through maritime forests and along dramatic, windswept bluffs with stunning ocean views.
Details: There’s an ~$8 vehicle entrance fee during peak season. Trails are open year-round.
Insider Tip: Wear sturdy walking shoes and be sure to check for ticks after hiking through the grassy or wooded areas.
- Wander Through Montauk Town
The central hub on the circle is where you’ll find a mix of surf shops, art galleries, and casual eateries. It’s a great place to grab supplies, browse for a souvenir, or enjoy a craft beer. The main public beach, Kirk Park Beach, is just across the street and has free parking (though it fills up fast!).
Details: A must-visit is the Montauk Brewing Company for a taste of local craft beer.
Insider Tip: This area is the most walkable part of Montauk and your best bet for finding a meal or essentials without needing a taxi.
- Experience the Bustling Montauk Harbor
Home to the largest commercial and sport fishing fleet in New York State, the harbor offers a different, more industrial vibe. Watch the boats come and go, see the day’s catch being unloaded, and breathe in the salty air. It’s a slice of authentic Montauk that many visitors miss.
Details: Located on the north side of the peninsula, near the LIRR station.
Insider Tip: This is one of the best spots on the island for sunset photos, offering a beautiful view over the calm bay waters away from the ocean-side crowds.
Sample Montauk Day Trip Itinerary
Here’s a blueprint for a packed but perfect day. The key is to start early and be strategic!
Morning (7:00 AM – 12:00 PM)
Your day begins now! Catch a train from Penn Station around 7:30 AM or hit the road in your car no later than 7:00 AM. Upon arrival around 10:30 AM, grab a coffee and a healthy breakfast burrito from Joni’s Kitchen. From there, head straight to the Montauk Point Lighthouse to explore the grounds and museum before the biggest crowds arrive.
Mid-Day (12:00 PM – 3:00 PM)
Time for the beach! Head to Ditch Plains to watch the surfers and have lunch from The Ditch Witch food truck. If you prefer a classic sit-down meal, now’s the time to visit The Lobster Roll (AKA “LUNCH”) for an iconic bite. Afterwards, relax on the sand at the more accessible Kirk Park Beach near town.
Afternoon (3:00 PM – 6:00 PM)
Choose your afternoon adventure. For stunning views and a bit of a walk, explore the dramatic bluffs at Camp Hero State Park or Shadmoor State Park. If you’d rather relax with a cold one, head to the Montauk Brewing Company for a tasting flight of their local brews in their lively beer garden.
Evening (6:00 PM onwards)
As the day winds down, catch a spectacular sunset over Fort Pond Bay or Montauk Harbor. Enjoy an early, casual dinner before heading back to the LIRR station or beginning the drive back to NYC, filled with fresh sea air and great memories.
Where to Eat: Montauk’s Best Food Spots for Day Trippers
From roadside shacks to chic sunset spots, Montauk’s food scene has something for everyone. Here are our top picks for a day trip.
Quick & Casual ($ – $$)
- John’s Drive-In: An old-school spot for amazing burgers, fries, and homemade ice cream.
- The Ditch Witch: A legendary food truck at Ditch Plains beach serving surfers for decades.
- Joni’s Kitchen: The go-to for healthy and delicious breakfast wraps, salads, and smoothies.
The Classic Experience ($$)
- The Lobster Roll (“LUNCH”): You can’t miss the iconic sign on the highway. A must-do for a classic lobster roll.
- Montauk Brewing Company: The perfect spot to sample local craft beer. They don’t serve food, but food trucks are often parked nearby.
Sunset Views & a Splurge ($$$)
- The Crow’s Nest Inn & Restaurant: Bohemian-chic atmosphere with stunning sunset views over Lake Montauk.
- Gurney’s Montauk Resort: For upscale, oceanfront dining with an unmatched view of the Atlantic.
Planning Your Visit: Practical Details
A little planning goes a long way for a smooth trip. Here are some key details to keep in mind.
- Seasonal Variations: Montauk is a summer town. Peak season is Memorial Day through Labor Day, when all attractions, shops, and restaurants are open. In the off-season (late fall to early spring), many places close or have severely limited hours. Always check websites before you go! The Fall Festival in October is a highlight of the shoulder season.
- Getting Around: Without a car, getting around can be tricky. The town is spread out. Taxis and ride-sharing services are available but can have long waits and high prices in summer. Renting a bike is a fantastic way to explore the main town area, Ditch Plains, and the harbor.
- Safety First: The Atlantic is powerful. Always be aware of strong rip currents at ocean beaches. If you’re hiking in state parks like Camp Hero, check for ticks afterward.
- Parking Woes: In July and August, parking is a major challenge. Public lots and street spots fill up very early in the morning. If driving, your best bet is to arrive before 9 AM to secure a spot.
Montauk Day Trip Budget Breakdown (Per Person)
Here’s a realistic look at what you can expect to spend for a full day trip from NYC.
| Expense | Low End Estimate | High End Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Transportation (Round Trip) | $65 (Off-Peak LIRR) | $90 (Peak LIRR/Bus) |
| Food & Drinks | $40 | $100 |
| Activities | $15 (Lighthouse) | $30 (Lighthouse + Park) |
| Total | ~$120 | ~$220 |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can you do a day trip to Montauk from NYC?
Yes, absolutely! It’s a long day, but with an early start and a good plan (like the one in this guide), it’s a fantastic getaway. To maximize your time and minimize stress, taking the LIRR train is often the best option for a day trip.
How much is a train ticket to Montauk from NYC?
A one-way LIRR ticket typically costs between $30.50 (off-peak) and $42.00 (peak) as of early 2025. Prices can vary by season and time, so always check the official MTA TrainTime app for the most current fares and schedules.
Is Montauk nicer than the Hamptons?
It’s not about “nicer,” it’s about a different vibe. The Hamptons (like East Hampton or Southampton) are generally more polished, with high-end boutiques and manicured estates. Montauk is more rugged, rustic, and laid-back, with a strong, authentic surfing and fishing culture. Think less designer handbags, more flip-flops and hoodies.
Can you go to Montauk without a car?
Yes, you can, and many people do! Take the LIRR or Hampton Jitney to get there. Once in Montauk, you can use local taxis, ride-sharing apps (be prepared for waits in summer), rent a bike for local travel, or even use the seasonal Hampton Hopper shuttle service to get around. The main town area is very walkable.
What to Pack Checklist
Pack smart to make the most of your day at “The End.”
- ✅ Comfortable walking shoes (you’ll do a lot of it!)
- ✅ Sunscreen, a hat, and sunglasses
- ✅ A light jacket or sweater (even in summer, it gets windy and cool by the water)
- ✅ Beach towel and swimsuit
- ✅ Camera and a portable phone charger
- ✅ Reusable water bottle and some snacks
TL;DR: The Perfect Montauk Day Trip in a Nutshell
In a hurry? Here’s the cheat sheet for an amazing day trip to Montauk:
- Best Way to Go: Take an early morning LIRR train to avoid traffic.
- Must-Do Activities: Visit the Lighthouse, watch surfers at Ditch Plains, and explore Camp Hero State Park.
- Must-Eat Food: A lobster roll from “LUNCH” or a burrito from the Ditch Witch food truck.
- Top Tip: Go on a weekday in the summer or anytime during the shoulder seasons (May, Sep, Oct) to avoid the biggest crowds.
- The Vibe: Laid-back, rugged, and windswept. It’s the “Un-Hamptons.”
